MAHA and Science
I support the good work of a new organization, MAHA Action (Make America Healthy Again). They are medical people, other experts (like me), and citizens who support the efforts of the Secretary of DHHS, Kennedy. They now have a weekly meeting (with several speakers) on Wednesday afternoon, for an hour or so. Here is a notice. Feel free to join if this is of interest to you.
I’ve volunteered to speak. If they say yes, this is what I was planning on saying:
I’m a scientist (a physicist), and would like to briefly touch on Science, which I believe needs to be discussed even more at the good MAHA meetings. This is quite relevant as ultimately, our healthcare successes and failures start with how well we adhere to real Science. I have just a few minutes of time today, so I will just give you some highlight points to reflect on. I’ll be glad to come back again and expand on them.
#1: Although the public strongly supports Science, some 97%± of the public doesn’t understand what Science actually is. This dichotomy means that this is a wide-open opportunity for self-serving parties to easily fool the public. All they have to do is to claim that what they are doing is “based on Science,” and 97% will not be the wiser... It’s important to note that citizens do not have to be scientists to be Critical Thinkers — and Critical Thinking is by far our best defense against any scam.
#2: The definition of Science is that it is a PROCESS. (At a recent meeting, Dr. Malone insightfully said that Science is a VERB. Yes!) The point of the process is to help us discover the Truths of our world. FYI, the most time-tested Science process is the Scientific Method.
A favorite tactic of snake oil salespeople is to substitute Political Science for Real Science. A key difference is that political science has nothing to do with the Scientific Method. Again, they make this substitution as 97% of the public will not be aware of the deception. Today, almost everything we hear the media proclaims to be “Science” is actually political science. Think Climate Change, our energy options, COVID policies, etc. Critical Thinkers are not taken in by the political science ruse.
#3: Another major strategy employed is to conflate Science and scientists to the public. They are not synonymous! Just like some priests are not holy people, and some lawyers are not law-abiding citizens, a large number of scientists (due to greed, political agendas, incompetence, etc.) have knowingly abandoned the principles of Science.
#4: Why are there more derelict scientists than priests or lawyers? Because there are no serious consequences for acting contrary to the standards of Science! If a priest acts counter to his vows, he can be defrocked. If a lawyer acts illegally, they can be disbarred. If a scientist goes afield, there is not only no punishment, but they are often rewarded by being employed by or given grants from like-minded parties.
#5: As a physicist, I am used to dealing with complicated matters, but I firmly believe that the simple route can frequently be the way to go. For example, regarding COVID, the public should have been told that they would be better off if they did such elementary things as strengthen their immune system, and took Vitamin D — which are actually Science-based. I never heard those words from Dr. Fauci or Dr. Birx.
#6: Surprisingly, I have not heard anyone discuss the Emergency Use Authorizations (EUAs). Bobby needs to fix the EUA process ASAP. Rather than analyzing injections, the problem is easier to understand by looking at treatments. E.g., Remdesivir got an EUA (with Scientific studies concluding that its effectiveness is -1%) while Ivermectin was not granted an EUA (even though Scientific studies concluded that its effectiveness is over 60%). This is one of many damning indictments of the EUA process. The evidence indicates that the perversion of the EUA process has led to some 500,000 Americans unnecessarily dying during the COVID period. This is why I say that the EUA process warrants a LOT of attention, both from us and from RFKjr.
#7: As Calley Means repeatedly stated recently in prior meetings, our opponents play the long game. That means that they have no qualms about embarking on a project that might take 20 to 30 years to come to fruition. Since most of us do not think in those time frames, we often miss what they are doing, even when it is right out in the open.
#8: A prime example of this is what has been happening in our K-12 schools. American children are purposefully having their Science education sabotaged. For example, in 48 States, K-12 children are not being taught the traditional Scientific Method — which has been a key underpinning of Science for many centuries. This is happening with what is called the Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS).
#9: Also, in 49 States, again via the NGSS, our children are being filled with progressive ideology in their Science classes.
#10: Worse, in 49 States, our children are purposefully being taught to NOT be Critical Thinkers, again under the NGSS guise of Science. This is being communicated by indoctrinating them with such ideas as: defer to experts, accept consensus views, go along with computer projections, etc. Note that this is exactly what these self-serving parties want US citizens to do when dealing with healthcare matters: go along with what you’re told and don’t ask any questions.
#11: Consider this number: 4 Million. That’s how many annual US high school graduates there are. A good estimate is that today, at least 3 Million of them are lemmings (i.e., NOT Critical Thinkers), who are also heavily propagandized with progressive ideology. What happens in relatively short order is that most of these will become voting citizens. Due to this pernicious long-term plan (that almost no one is doing anything meaningful about), they will soon become the majority of American voters.
#12: Lastly, if we do not fix this K-12 Science debacle quickly, the results will be catastrophic and irreversible.
So, my plea is that citizens need to do more Critical Thinking, pay more attention to what is real Science, and speak up about how Science is being taught in our K-12 education system — which is a disaster.
Here is other information from this scientist that you might find interesting:
I am now offering incentives for you to sign up new subscribers!
I also consider reader submissions on Critical Thinking on my topics of interest.
My commentaries are my opinion about the material discussed therein, based on the information I have. If any readers have different information, please share it. If it is credible, I will be glad to reconsider my position.
Check out the Archives of this Critical Thinking substack.
C19Science.info is my one-page website that covers the lack of genuine Science behind our COVID-19 policies.
Election-Integrity.info is my one-page website that lists multiple major reports on the election integrity issue.
WiseEnergy.org is my multi-page website that discusses the Science (or lack thereof) behind our energy options.
Media Balance Newsletter: a free, twice-a-month newsletter that covers what the mainstream media does not do, on issues from climate to COVID, elections to education, renewables to religion, etc. Here are the Newsletter’s 2025 Archives. Please send me an email to get your free copy. When emailing me, please make sure to include your full name and the state where you live. (Of course, you can cancel the Media Balance Newsletter at any time - but why would you?
Thanks for reading Critically Thinking About Select Societal Issues! Please pass a link to this article on to other associates who might benefit. They can subscribe for FREE to receive new posts (typically about twice a week).
John,
Are you awake and alert 24/7? The wisdom you write and sometimes just pass along is so worth any decent person's time to read and digest ...... AND pass along.
It has become obvious that so-called "Artificial Intelligence", the latest and greatest in our world of technical progress, is likely the single most effective way to replace critical thinking with lemming mentality amongst the populations of the world if subversively used as it is being used in our schools and universities in the name of education. A.I. is really F.I. (Fake Intelligence) when promoted and used in such ways.
Thanks for sharing.
Russ Babcock
You are so right! Especially, EUA (corrupt way to distribute something dangerous without penalty), Scientific Method not being taught, and always the lack of critical thinking skills. PARENTS need to teach their children to be skeptical and how to determine if their skepticism is correct. But a parent who hasn't been taught that can't teach it. Everything becomes about feelings. I see it all too often in the workplace now. Too many young workers are not problem solvers. They are not curious enough to solve a problem, small as it might be. Lack of critical thinking begets mediocrity, then mediocrity becomes the norm and accepted because of "feelings". Like you wrote, the lemmings will become the majority and goodbye excellence.